Am I the only one who gets sucked into buying stuff at mall kiosks, eventho I know it’s probably cheaper elsewhere? I caved and bought some wood 3D puzzle today, but after putting it together….the pieces don’t fit together quite right and it doesn’t look quite as good as the display. *sigh* should have known. Anyways, recently, it seems like the higher end skincare is suddenly obsessed with rose. It’s always been a pretty popular ingredient, but suddenly Fresh came out with a whole rose skincare line last year, and Peter Thomas Roth came out with a couple rose products this year. The fancy little thing that tickled my fancy this time is of course the rose mask. Since my current favorite is Fresh rose mask, I’m curious about how this will compare.
First impression: Fresh is brown with rose petal bits and a runny gel consistency, while PTR is a light pink with a gel cream consistency. Fresh have a mild round rose scent. PTR have a mild slightly sharper/sweet rose scent. I previously made some rosewater from DIY and Fresh smells very similar to the pot of rosewater I made while PTR smells more like the bouquet of fresh roses I picked, before I put the petals in water (I wonder if it’s due to the rose stem cell blah blah mentioned). It sort of make sense, since Fresh take a somewhat natural approach to skincare while PTR takes a more scientific approach.
Ingredients: Both starts with water and Butylene glycol (a humectant) along with Rosa damascena flower oil, rose water, glycerin and aloe vera. However, PTR uses five types of roses, mostly oil and extracts, while Fresh uses two types of roses, the flower itself and the water are higher on the ingredients list. Fresh also contains more calming ingredients like chamomile and cucumber as well as aloe vera. Now, while ingredients are usually listed from the most to least, the concentration of each ingredients are not revealed, so it’s not like there is the same amount of ingredient #5 in product A as the amount of ingredient #5 in product B. In general the important stuff are in the first 10 listed. My impression is that PTR uses more potent or higher concentration of roses while Fresh contains more calming ingredients and less chemicals. Not a big deal for most, but the higher concentration of rose oil may be irritating for some. It’s kind of the same with cucumber and lavender (here’s a great breakdown on why you should not be paranoid of lavender, which some people are allergic to). Unless you know you are super sensitive/get irritation from plant oils, this should be a non-issue, both masks’ got good stuff and no parabens.
Thoughts: While Fresh is smaller and more expensive than PTR, it have a more runny consistency so you need less of it per application. PTR also comes in a big 5oz jar, which is excellent if you are a regular user of hydrating masks but skincare products usually lose their effect/go bad within 2 years, so if you can’t finish it within that time, it’s best to get a new one. PTR have the additional benefit of being used over moisturizer, so if you sleep in a dry environment, this may give your skincare a little boost. If you are a regular user of hydrating mask and have no problem with higher concentration of rose, go for PTR. Also, PTR rose have a slightly thicker/creamier consistency than cucumber. I like the calming ingredients and the feel of Fresh rose and PTR cucumber, but 5oz is too much for me, so I will stick with Fresh instead. They are both great for dry/combo skin, altho if you are really really dry, then you might consider one of the non-drying masks like Glamglow Thirstymud or Fresh Black Tea.
So that’s that, and now we are switching gears to skincare journal Continue reading Skincare Journal wk17: Roses everywhere